By now you’ve most likely seen the video on this post Live broadcast of a Cochlear Implant surgery.
Interesting video of how a cochlear implant surgery is done, yes?
Some of you may not be aware that there is controversy over Cochlear Implants (CI for short).
Since FDA has changed the age limits for CI, this has meant that deaf babies as young as 6 months old can be implanted. A large number of medical professionals, audiologists and speech specialists advocate the use of the Auditory Verbal Therapy (AVT) with the CI. The Auditory Verbal Approach means daily, consistent training of deaf children in learning how to hear and speak over a period of months if not years. This approach is sponsored by organizations like Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing. AG Bell Academy Web site. Note their slogan “For listening and spoken language.”
A side note: Alexander Graham Bell is known for his invention of the telephone. He was also a Eugenicist whose ideas about people that he considered defective centered on the deaf. Ironically, he was married to a deaf woman and was a close friend of deaf-blind Helen Keller. Source: Wikipedia. Scroll down to the Eugenics section.
With the rise of CI being performed on deaf children, AVT has been on the rise as well. Also, there is an increasing popularity in teaching American Sign Language to hearing babies. Signing with your baby increases their linguistic acquisition, their intelligence, and makes communication with parents and children easier.
Yet I question: Why are deaf babies treated differently from hearing babies? Sign language is the native language of the deaf. Why do deaf children have to learn how to listen with their greatest weakness – hearing? Why have CI surgeries that may or may not restore enough hearing to be usable?
I find it interesting that deafness is a non-debilitating condition that is being operated on. The suffering that deaf people have comes from others denying them their native language (ASL) and Deafhood. I realize that there are parents who feel that implanting their deaf child is the best decision, and I have to respect that. However, if an implanted child is taught American Sign Language and Deafhood, that is better. Because an implanted child is still deaf, and American Sign Language is the only language that is 100% accessible for the deaf. Lip reading shows 30-35% of the English language. Hearing aids and CIs don’t always provide enough hearing to be dependable alone. A CI does not make a deaf baby hear the same as a hearing baby.
Discussion of language acquisition in babies brought about the Greatest Irony, which Amy Cohen Efron so well told through her vlog series that has been circulating on the deaf blogsphere. She has a updated copy with voice interpretation for the hearing. Video Link here.
I’ve always wanted to share this with my general audience because of our Deaf population here in the area. There is a desperate need for the public to understand the Deaf perspective. We have a Deaf and Hard of Hearing panel that fields questions from parents of Deaf/HoH children. CIs are generally viewed by the local Deaf community as not necessary for the clinically deaf child. If a deaf person is old enough to make the decision to get the CI, that is their personal decision. However, once a CI is implanted, it cannot be taken out unless there is a serious medical harm to the body.
I am aware that some people think that Deaf people are such angry people. If you think about it, Deaf people have a very good reason to be angry. They have had an epiphany. It is the realization that being deaf is not bad, and the only bad has been coming from people who view deafness in a negative light. My blog up to now, have featured stories and comments from living Deaf people who lead full lives, work, vote, and think about deep issues. There is nothing bad about being Deaf unless someone makes a big deal out of it.
A fellow Deaf vlogger said eloquently that without the emotion Anger to drive for changes, there would be no progression, no Deafhood, just like African-Americans and Womens’ rights fighting for equal civil rights. But the momentum must keep going until the word Audism (discrimination/prejudice of deafness) is no longer needed.